How to Make Gingerbread Cookies

As a ratio baker, I use ratios and weights to bake, so this is more of a how to guide than an actual recipe.

Ratio baking cookies has eluded me since I tried them last year. This year, with the holidays coming up and with needing to entertain young cooped up children (thanks, pandemic), I decided to try cookies again. With Christmas coming up, gingerbread cookies felt like a fun idea. What child wouldn’t like squirting icing onto gingerbread men and women?

The cookie ratio is 3:2:1, which means 3 parts flour to 2 parts fat to 1 part sugar. The problem I had last time was I only got a dry shortbread, of which I was not a fan. Tons of research later, I discovered the ratio should actually be more like 3:2:2 so the fat and sugar should weigh about the same. What a game changer that has been! With it, I’ve made gingerbread cookies and apple pie cookies.

I also discovered a secret about cookies. Shh! Eggs are not strictly necessary. See, the ratio doesn’t mention them, but I’ve only made one or two cookies that don’t call for eggs. I decided that, since they didn’t seem to be necessary, I simply wasn’t going to use them. At least, not for now, and not for my gingerbread cookies. None of us missed the eggs. Perfect for people who can’t or don’t eat eggs!

You Will Need

Flour

Fat (butter)

Brown sugar

Gingerbread spice

Honey

Vanilla extract

Baking soda

The Cookie Ratio

The cookie ratio I used is 3:2:2. It’s 3 parts flour to 2 parts butter to 2 parts sugar. That means the butter and sugar should weigh about the same. To get the weight of the flour, divide the weight of the butter (or sugar) in half and then multiply by 3.

How to Make Gingerbread Cookies

Gingerbread usually uses molasses, but I never have molasses on hand. I’ve read honey and sugar are common, so I substituted molasses for brown sugar and honey so I get the sweetness and the darker color. Though, if you have molasses, no reason not to use it!

Preheat oven to 375 degrees and prepare a lightly greased or parchment paper covered cookie sheet.

The honey and brown sugar serve as the sugar so their combined weight should be about equal to the weigh of the butter. One stick of butter weighs 113 grams so, if you use one stick of butter, the combined weight of the honey and brown sugar should be around 113 grams.

Cream the brown sugar, honey, and butter. Add the vanilla extract and mix well.

Add the flour, baking soda, and gingerbread spice. Mix well.

Wrap the dough in plastic wrap and refrigerate for about an hour. If refrigerated for longer, the dough will harden and will need to sit at room temperature until it softens enough to be rolled out.

After refrigerating the dough, place it on a floured surface and roll to desired thickness. Cut into shapes and place on cookie sheets. These cookies have very little spread, so placing them about an inch apart will work fine. The thinner they are, the crisper they will be.

Bake for about 10-12 minutes, but be careful as, once it starts to darken, it turns over into burnt very quickly, so remove once the edges start to darken.

What I Did

When I don’t have to, I don’t cut up butter, so I started with one stick of butter (113 grams).

The cookie ratio of 3:2:2 calls for the sugar to be about the same weight as the butter. I put honey and brown sugar into my mixing bowl, making sure their combined weight was about 113 grams. Since my kids aren’t fans of the flavor of honey, I used more brown sugar than honey.

To the sugar I added the softened butter and creamed them together and then mixed in the vanilla extract.

To another bowl, I weighed out my flour. To get the weight, I divided 113 by 2 and then multiplied that number by 3 to get approximately 170 grams of flour.

I added about a teaspoon of baking soda, a couple of tablespoons of gingerbread spice, and just a pinch of salt to the flour. This was then added to the butter and sugar mixture. I mixed it until it was fully combined and became a soft dough.

Then I wrapped the dough in plastic wrap and put it in the fridge for about an hour.

I liberally floured my surface and rolling pin and floured both sides of the dough. My kids have been looking for the crispier gingerbread people, so I rolled my dough to about an 1/8 of an inch or so (or, as flat and thin as I dared) before letting them cut out the people. Do make sure the dough and the surface are well-floured as the dough has a tendency to stick to anything not floured enough. Then I placed the shapes on a prepared cookie sheet.

My cookies backed at 375 for about 12 to 15 minutes. When fully cooled, I made icing from powdered sugar and water (the more liquid you add, the runnier it will be) and decorated, following a 3 year old’s directions.

14 thoughts on “How to Make Gingerbread Cookies

      1. They’re much stronger in flavor. I bought some and wasn’t sure what to do with them because of that. I’ve had black walnut ice cream before, that was delicious. I think the cream softened their flavor

        Like

  1. I saw you weren’t thrilled with the plain 1-2-3 recipe – does this ratio actually make a dough for you? I tried it today with some lemon zest and poppy seeds and it was so dry, like pie crust before you add water. I had to mix in some lemon juice to make it hold together but wasn’t sure how dry it should be so the cookies are pretty dry after baking. I weighed everything so I’m not sure what went wrong with the recipe but definitely did not create a workable dough.

    Like

    1. Ratio baking cookies is still a work in progress for me, though I’ve found the 3-2-2, flour to sugar to fat, has tended to work out a little better than the 1-2-3 ratio. Since I was aiming for the drier, crispier gingerbread cookies, the 3-2-2 worked out well for me, though for a different kind of cookie the ratio might need to be tweaked, and eggs would probably help loosen up the dough; I just didn’t find them necessary for the gingerbread cookies.
      If you’re interested in experimenting yourself, I’ve found this page to be helpful:
      http://sugarkissed.net/cookie-chemistry/

      I’m very sorry this wasn’t able to help you create a workable dough.

      Like

  2. No worries! Just trying to figure out if there’s an issue with my ingredients. I’d rather not waste a ton of butter on inedible cookies trying to tweak the ratio but it may be necessary. 🙂

    Like

    1. I’m still figuring it out, too, and hate wasting butter as well. The good thing about using weights is that it can easily be scaled down. When I try new things, I typically start with about half a stick of butter so it doesn’t feel so wasteful. Thank you for your understanding, and happy baking!

      Like

Chat with me

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.